Cup of herbal tea by an apartment window overlooking the city
on November 18, 2026

The Great Forgetting: How the Industrial Age Moved Us Indoors

Part 2 of 6 · The Way Back to the Garden. Missed Part 1? Start here.

On Sunday, 18 November 1883, the people of North America lived through a strange day. Some of them later called it "the day of two noons."

Until then, every town kept its own time. Noon was simply the moment the sun stood highest in the sky, so noon in Toronto, noon in Kingston and noon in Montreal all fell a few minutes apart. Nobody minded much, because nobody needed to be anywhere that fast.

Then came the railways. Trains needed timetables, and timetables could not work with hundreds of local noons. A railway engineer named Sandford Fleming had presented a solution here in Toronto a few years earlier: divide the world into time zones, one hour apart. At noon on 18 November 1883, the railways of Canada and the United States reset their clocks to the new system. In many towns, the clocks struck noon, and then, a little later, struck noon again.

It sounds like a small, practical fix. But think about what changed that day. For all of human history, the day had followed the sun. From then on, it would follow the clock.

From the sun to the clock

In Part 1, we followed herbs through four thousand years of ordinary life: clay tablets, scrolls, monastery gardens and a grandfather's garden full of crickets and wind. In all of those places, life moved with the light and the seasons. You planted when the ground warmed. You picked flowers when they opened. You dried leaves in late summer for the winter ahead.

The industrial age brought a new kind of rhythm. Factory whistles announced the start of a shift. Work happened at the same hours whether it was June or January, sunny or grey. The clock didn't care what was flowering outside, and slowly, neither did we.

From the village to the city

The machines were in the towns, so the people moved to the towns.

England was the first country to cross the line. Its census of 1851 showed that, for the first time anywhere, more people lived in towns and cities than in the countryside. The rest of the world followed over the next century and a half. In 1950, about 30% of the world's people lived in cities. Today it's more than half, and the United Nations expects it to reach roughly two-thirds by 2050.

A move to the city didn't just mean a new address. It meant leaving behind the garden by the door, the fields at the edge of the village, and the older neighbour who knew which leaves to pick in May.

From the garden to the shelf

In 1916, a grocer in Memphis named Clarence Saunders opened a shop called Piggly Wiggly. Instead of handing a list to a clerk behind a counter, customers walked the aisles themselves and picked packages from the shelves. It was the world's first self-service grocery store, and the idea spread quickly.

It was convenient, and in many ways wonderful. But it quietly changed our relationship with plants. Food and herbs stopped being something you grew, picked, dried and stored. They became products: packed somewhere else, by someone else, with a label on the front. The knowledge that once lived in a grandmother's hands began to live on the back of a box, or nowhere at all.

From outdoors to indoors

The last step happened so gradually that most of us never noticed it.

When researchers funded by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency asked thousands of Americans to keep diaries of where they spent their time, the answer was striking: on average, about 87% of the day indoors, and another 6% or so inside a car or bus. That leaves only a sliver of the day under the open sky. As one writer who dug into the study put it, we have become, more or less, an indoor species.

Think about your own Tuesday. Bedroom, kitchen, car or subway, office, screen, kitchen again, bedroom. For many of us, the most "nature" we see on a weekday is the weather app.

Not a villain story

We don't want to tell this as a story with a villain. The industrial age brought clean water, warm homes, modern medicine and the very screen you're reading this on. Few of us would trade them back.

But progress has a habit of keeping the big things and dropping the small ones. And somewhere between the factory whistle and the self-checkout, a very small thing got dropped: the everyday habit of living close to plants. Picking a few leaves. Waiting for the kettle. Watching the colour of a cup change as the herbs open up.

That habit didn't disappear everywhere at once. In plenty of city apartments, from Tehran to Toronto, a grandmother still keeps a little pot of dried flowers steeping on the stove in the evening. It's a thin thread, but it's still there. That's what we call the great forgetting: not a loss we chose, just a thousand small conveniences that added up.

So what did it cost us?

If our days now follow the clock instead of the sun, if our food comes from shelves instead of gardens, and if we spend almost all our hours under a roof, what did we leave behind along the way? It turns out to be more than a garden. It's a sense of the seasons, the names of the plants around us, and something that's surprisingly hard to find today: real quiet.

That's Part 3: What We Lost Along the Way.


The Way Back to the Garden

  1. The Oldest Recipe in the World
  2. The Great Forgetting (you are here)
  3. What We Lost Along the Way: rhythm, seasons and the names of plants
  4. A Cup Around the World: herbal rituals from Tehran to Buenos Aires
  5. Small Rituals, Big Return: bringing nature back into an ordinary day
  6. Your Year in Herbs: a seasonal ritual guide

A small way to bring the garden back indoors: our seven organic herbal tea blends, hand-blended in small batches here in Toronto, in biodegradable tea bags. Find your blend.

We share the history of herbs as culture and tradition. This article is not medical advice.

About the Author

Dadar F.

Dadar F. is the founder of Earthly Herbs and a trained nursing professional. Raised between the fragrant herb gardens of his grandfather’s home and the quiet rhythms of nature, he built Earthly Herbs to reconnect people with the healing wisdom of plants. Now based in Canada, he blends traditional herbal knowledge with a wellness-forward approach to everyday living.

Read more about Dadar →